ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Jacob Bielfeld’s “On the Decline of States” (1760) and its Relevance for Today
Author: Reinert Erik S.
Session: Historical Political Economy Author: Erik S. Reinert In a now virtually forgotten economic bestseller, Institutions Politiques, German Economist Jacob Bielfeld (1717-1770), an advisor to Frederick the Great of Prussia, has a very comprehensive and – as opposed to Spengler’s generalisations 150 years later – very concrete, detailed and specific list of the factors which cause the decline of nations. This paper brings the first ever English translation of this chapter with a brief discussion arguing for a renewed relevance not only of the factors and mechanisms pointed to by Bielfeld, but also of Bielfeld’s fact-based and taxonomic approach to economic understanding. An important reason for re-publishing Bielfeld’s chapter on the decline of nations is that it compares so favourably with the narrow focus of modern economic theory on the subject, exemplified in Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson’s Why Nations Fail. Europe at the time of Bielfeld presented a large number of nations from which to draw experiences. The 1648 Peace of Westphalia had produced around 400 independent states in Germany alone, although by 1760 the number had decreased considerably. Due to his position at the Court of Frederick the Great and in Prussia’s Foreign Service, Bielfeld had unique access to information from many nations. Precisely because of this privileged access to information, Bielfeld’s correspondence was published and translated (from French) also into German and English. The rich sample of different nations pursuing different strategies in different contexts allows Bielfeld a large number of national case-studies on which to draw. Closer to our time, The Great Depression also provided a setting where national strategies differed – e.g. whether to stay on the Gold Standard or not – from which nations could learn from each other. With today’s coordinated policies and one-size-fits-all approach of the European Union, the diversity from which Bielfeld and his contemporaries could draw is gone. Europe has lost a diversity which historically probably has been crucial to its success, becoming “standardised” and “homogenised” in a lot of areas from a single currency to bank supervision to standardisation of shapes of cucumbers to research policy. I suggest this chapter be read in the spirit of evolutionary economics, where the “market” is so much more than a mechanism setting prices. At the time of Bielfeld Europe was an arena where different ideas, in the form of laws, types of government, efficiency of armaments, and economic policy were continuously compared and tested against each other, attempting to arrive at a “best practice” from a huge number of cases. As opposed to a unified China, Europe at the time was a huge living laboratory. From an evolutionary perspective , rather than from one of equilibrium, today’s Europe is facing decline where seemingly only one solution is considered.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)