ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Is Leon Walras a precursor of left-libertarianism?
Author: Gharbi Jean-Sébastien, Sekerler Richiardi Pelin


Left-libertarians endorse both full self-ownership and common ownership of natural resources. For this reason, they present Leon Walras, who advocates full ownership of personal faculties and common ownership of land, as one of their precursors. This theoretical lineage, many times asserted (Steiner, 1994, p. 236, note 13 ; Vallentyne, 1999, p. 860, note 2 ; Vallentyne & Steiner, 2000, p. 217), has nevertheless never been fully developed by left wing libertarians who either accept such an interpretation without questioning it (Cohen, 1995, p. 118 ; Fried, 2004, p. 66) or do not even mention it. The only source which analyses this relation is Bourdeau (2006) who distinguishes Walras' republicanism from contemporary left-libertarianism by showing that these two positions are premised on different conceptions of appropriation of natural resources. The point we make is this way to distinguish these two positions need to be discussed. For this purpose, first, we highlight the similarities between the Walrasian and left-libertarian definitions of self-ownership and ownership of natural resources. While both positions do indeed lead to the same kind of questioning of the classical term "ownership" of natural resources, our objective is not to present Walras as a left-libertarian on the basis of these similarities. Second, we underline the divergences between Walras’ theory of ownership and the theory of social justice advocated by left-libertarians: (a) unlike left-libertarians, Walras does not endorse the distribution of income obtained from lands, but he advocates that such income should be used for financing the State; (b) Walras and left libertarians have different opinions about what "common ownership" means; and (c) the notions of State used by Walras and libertarians differ fundamentally. We conclude that present Leon Walras as a precursor of left-libertarianism amounts to give in to homonymy, i.e. to pay an exclusive attention to the syntax or to the form of their respective theories, to the detriment of their meanings - and of their ontologies.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.