ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Modern agency considered in relation to the parts of the internal and external in the formation of order.
Author: Dixon William, Wilson David


Any consideration of issues of order must form a view of the relation between the internal and external in establishing an order. Political economy was distinctive in understanding a particular configuration of that relation in which order could be reached through a free self-interest. Of course we know that in Smith and Ricardo some limits to the pursuit of interest were accepted and that there was concern about the framework in which interest should be pursued. Some external reference was required. Even so, classical political economy marked a distinctive moment in the understanding of the internal and external. We examine this moment in terms of the relation between self (internal) – practice (order) – doctrine (external). For Smith the conception of a competent self meant that external doctrine had only a small part, the self being capacitated for moral conduct. However, Smith’s conception, applicable in principle to all people, was not readily applicable when different orders of interest were considered. While some may connive with others against the public others may actually find no benefit from the proposed order, whether by fact or by lack of adequate understanding, so rendering moral conduct irrelevant or dysfunctional. It is this latter group, in particular the poor, the labourer etc. that concerns us here. We examine how the interest and competence of the poor were considered. We treat this first through the general problem as dealt with subsequent to Hobbes and leading to Smith. We highlight here not just the competent self but also the ‘trial’ or life as probation in which that competence is exercised. Depending on the level of competence and the nature of the ‘trial’ some element of external doctrine was needed to keep things in line. In particular we examine the idea of trial as it evolved into a conception of political economy as a system, while doctrine, we examine in terms of religion. We follow through such writers as, Arthur Young, Joseph Townsend, Thomas Malthus and then Thomas Chalmers. Their work treated in this manner also allows by contrast some reflection on the nature of modern economics.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.