ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Competition
Author: SALVADORI Neri, Signorino Rodolfo


The paper was written as an entry for Volume 3 of the Handbook of the History of Economic Analysis, edited by Gilbert Faccarello and Heinz D. Kurz, Cheltenham, UK and Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar, forthcoming. Our paper is built around three basic claims. First, ever since economics has become an autonomous scientific discipline, the notion of competition has been one of its main theoretical pillars. In particular as concern the theory of value, the analysis of competition carried out by such late seventeenth – mid eighteenth century authors as William Petty, François Quesnay, Richard Cantillon, Anne Robert Jacques Turgot, David Hume and, of course, Adam Smith has proved crucial to free the theory of price determination from previous Scholasticist and Middle Ages influences and to confer it its present-day scientific status. Second, the historical evolution of the concept of competition largely overlaps with that of economic theory itself. This may explain why, in the course of time, the same word ‘competition’ has undergone through substantive shifts of meaning. Though the same may be said for many other central theoretical notions in economics –value, equilibrium, income distribution etc.– yet, what is peculiar of ‘competition’ is that “the new meaning of competition precludes the old; that the perfect competition of modern analysis is incompatible with the competitive behaviour of the classical and early neoclassical periods” (High 2001, p. xiv). Accordingly, we have developed our analysis of the different meanings assumed by the word competition by means of a tentative four-fold taxonomy: competition as i) rivarly in a race (Classical and early Neoclassical), ii) a specific market structure (Neoclassical), iii) a discovery procedure (Neo-Austrian) and, finally, iv) class struggle (Neo-Marxian). Third, the variety of meanings attached to the notion of competition by different schools of thought may explain, at a normative level, the variety of policy prescriptions endorsed by different schools of antitrust scholars. The classical example at this regard is that of a firm undrercutting its rivals. An antitrus scholar imbued with the ‘rivarly in a race’ notion of competition would likely greet this fact as a sign of healthy and vigourous competition; while an antitrust scholar imbued with the ‘specific market structure’ notion of competition would likely consider this fact as potential instance of a predatory pricing intent and thus would hurry a careful antitrust scrutiny.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.