ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: RICARDO’S REACTION TO SMITH’S “ORIGINAL ERROR” RESPECTING VALUE
Author: MEACCI Ferdinando
In a well-known letter to James Mill, Ricardo pointed out that “in reading Adam Smith, again, I find many opinions to question, all I believe founded on his original error respecting value”. In Sraffa’s introduction to Ricardo’s Principles, Smith’s “original error” has been identified with the latter’s theory that “the price of commodities is arrived at by a process of adding up the wages, profit and rent”; i.e. with what is known today as the “adding-up theory of value”. On the other hand, the further statement, entered by Ricardo immediately after his criticism of Smith’s “original error”, that “he is particularly faulty in the chapter on bounties” has been considered by Hollander (1992) as directed not so much to one of those “opinions to question” but directly as “the key to Ricardo’s Principles”. If, however, the term “original” is intended as the “source” of Smith’s “many opinions to question” (rather than as an “initial” or an “unprecedented” step in a long series of such opinions); and if the concept of value is intended as the “principle from which everything descends” (Napoleoni, 1982), it seems more appropriate to trace Ricardo’s criticism of Smith’s “original error” to the criticism, set out right at the beginning of his Principles, of Smith’s theory of value as distinct from, and preceding, the theory of distribution. It is from this foundation of Ricardo’s thought that our examination of his immediate and further reactions to Smith’s “original error” begins. This twofold reaction will be examined below in two steps. The first step consists in highlighting the often ambiguous and inaccurate language by which Smith presents his theory first of value and then of distribution; and in assessing whether Ricardo’s immediate reaction is affected by that ambiguous and inaccurate language more than by the analysis concealed by it. The second step is more properly focused on the diverging conclusions drawn by Smith and Ricardo from the double principle of value expounded by the one and from the further reaction developed by the other. These diverging conclusions will be examined in the light 1) of the role assigned to rent in the so-called “adding-up theory of value”; 2) of the principle of demand and supply in determining the (natural and market) price of labour (as distinct from that of its products); and 3) of the wage-profit inverse relationship in a static and in a dynamic context.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)