ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: On the Marxian Notion of Ideology and Economics
Author: Özel Hüseyin


The Marxian notion of ideology has generally been understood in two related but distinct, and potentially conflicting, senses: in the first, the "ideological superstructure" conception, ideology is characterized by its function to facilitate the reproduction of the relations of production, and in the second, "false consciousness" conception, ideology is meant to be a distorted picture of the reality. However, since in the first conception the constitutive role of ideology (at the individual and or the societal level, à la Althusser and even a là Foucault) is emphasized, this causes the "hermeneutic" insight to be relevant. Yet this brings about the question whether ideology could really be "false", for its constitutive role makes it real and "right" (a "post-modern" theme). Therefore, in this paper an attempt to bridge these two notions of ideology is made and it is argued that a proper discussion of the Marxian notion of ideology as "false consciousness" should be considered in three interconnected "moments": In the first, the "holistic" or the "hermeneutic moment", the fact that prevalence of commodity fetishism and alienation makes the very reality in capitalism inverted or "false" is considered. Ideology is, then, an "unreflective reflection" of this falsity, hence, "false consciousness". Since this consciousness is independent of the specific section or class in the society, or it is the "common denomination" (à la Karel Kosík) that unites, say, a capitalist and a worker, it is the basic constituent of the capitalist society (a theme comes from early writings of Marx). In the second, the "Functional Moment", it is emphasized that ideology is class-dependent, but still created by the holistic vision; here reified, mystified social relations are not only reflected uncritically, but they are also idealized, naturalized and eternalized; at this level, ideology is characterized by its function in the reproduction process (as in Althusser’s notion of the “ideological state apparatuses’). Finally, in the third, the "individual moment", those (mostly psychological) mechanisms which are important in maintenance of ideological beliefs are considered. The significance of this moment is that these acts, or at least the attempts (of self-deception, wishful thinking, or willful ignorance) are for the most part intentional. In other words, individuals participate in the reproduction of ideology in an active way, although they have the potential not to fall under the "spell" of ideology. In the present paper, the relations/interactions among these three moments are explored and it is argued that without these moments taken together, the analysis of ideology is doomed to be relapsed into individualism, holism, or psychologism, depending on which moment is emphasized. And finally, Neoclassical economics is argued to be a good example that validates this conceptual framework, that is, it is an "ideological" construct effective in all these three "moments".

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.