ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: What is required to supplant neoclassical economics? - a philosophical appraisal
Author: Kellecioglu Deniz
This paper work employs relevant sections of philosophy of science to understand how the neoclassical school-of-thought attained dominance within economics. This understanding, in turn, is utilised to discern elements for a successful supplanting process to occur at present times. The findings suggest that philosophy of science provides an overlapping array of usefulness in understanding theory-change within economics. Karl Popper’s philosophy of falsification represent a procedure to displace economic narratives. Thomas Kuhn’s philosophy is useful in the same regard, albeit with a different vantage point, in which a dominant ‘paradigm’, which neoclassical theory may be looked upon, gain and retain its dominance. Imre Lakatos‘ philosophy of scientific research programmes is useful with concepts of a “hard core” of the dominant programme and its “protective belt”. Paul Feyerabend’s philosophy offers an open minded attitude to the three frameworks mentioned above, while being critical to any uniform vantage point to knowledge generation. Among others, Feyerabend advanced that a proliferation of theories will stimulate a free development of knowledge, society and the individual. In relation, proponents of the critical theory school argue that this proliferation is obstructed by extra-scientific factors and interests. The philosophical underpinnings above are employed in providing a historical narrative for neoclassical economics, which suggests that it attained dominance within economics by the occurrence of the following elements: * conjuncture - such as the economic crises in the 1970s, * dissimilarity - as a counteraction to contested (‘falsified’) schools, such as Keynesianism; * simpleness - for popular appeal (a meta-philosophy); * academic support - endorsements by economists at large; and, most importantly, * elite appropriation - commendation and co-optation by powerful interest groups. Hence, judging by the philosophical and historical interpretation above, it is necessary to actively engage in intra-scientific (ii., iii., and iv.) and extra-scientific (i. and v.) fields of change in order to supplant spheres of the neoclassical school. In doing so, it is concluded that the greatest task is to overcome and transcend elite appropriation.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)