ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Ziber's influence on Tugan-Baranovsky
Author: Allisson François


Tugan-Baranovsky is the author of a theory of value built on a synthesis between marginal utility and the "labour theory". The reader of his publications on the subject (written between 1890 and 1919) may be puzzled by the apparent changing content that the Russian economist gave to the expression "labour theory". For instance, in 1890 (before Engels published the third volume of Capital on the basis of Marx's drafts), Tugan-Baranovsky incidentally wrote that the labour theory was Ricardo's or Marx's theory of value, entailing that they were identical. Later, when Tugan-Baranovsky was engaged in a systematic critique of Marx's theory at the turn of the twentieth century, he concluded that Ricardo and Marx had not the same theory, as he distinguished between Ricardo's costs of production and Marx's labour values. Yet, as and when his own theory of value got more complex in the 1910s, Tugan-Baranovsky resorted to both notions (labour values and costs of production), implying that Ricardo and Marx could and should co-exist in the same theory. The least that can be said is that the relation between Ricardo and Marx in Tugan-Baranovsky's theory of value is difficult to follow. This paper suggests that once the reader takes into account Ziber's influence on Tugan-Baranovsky, then most difficulties concerning Ricardo and Marx, if they do not vanish, at least they become intelligible. Our aim is to define this influence, to give it a theoretical and material substance through a body of direct and indirect evidences. To this purpose, the paper specifies relevant aspects of Ziber's theory of value that partly shaped Tugan-Baranovsky's economic thought: the average method, the emphasis on the social economy and on labour values, and the characterisation of Marx vis-à-vis Ricardo. These aspects allowed us to reconstruct Ziber's influence on Tugan-Baranovsky.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.