ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Western Economics in Socialist China: the Case of the 1957 Discussion
Author: Borokh Olga


The aim of this paper is to explore the significance of 1957 discussion on the research and teaching of economics in China. After the PRC was established in 1949 Marxist political economy became dominant and Soviet influence increased. During the “hundred flowers” campaign six influential Chinese economists led by Prof. Chen Zhenhan from Beijing University wrote an “Opinion” letter to express their dissatisfaction with government-imposed constraints. The backbone of the group were Western-trained economists (Chen Zhenhan, Luo Zhiru and Wu Baosan got their doctorate degrees from Harvard University, Xu Yunan – from Cambridge University). The first section of the paper outlines the main ideas of the “Opinion”. Chinese scholars proposed to diminish the influence of ideological dogmatism in economic research and criticized the trend of wholesale introduction of Soviet political economy that led to underestimation of scholarly value of the Western economic thought. They raised the problem of borrowing of useful concepts and methods from the West, focusing on the Keynesian multiplier and marginal analysis. The “Opinion” recommended better co-operation between the government officials and the economists in order to avoid arbitrary subjective decisions and “blind” trial-and-error approach in economic policy. The signatories blamed the authorities for ideological mistrust in “bourgeois” professional economists and for hiding important economic data (especially in banking and finances) from the researchers. The second section analyzes the academic dimension of subsequent critical campaign that was launched against the authors of the “Opinion”. Although some of the opponents came forward with superficial accusations in attempts to undermine Marxism and restore “bourgeois” economics, there were also theoretical counterarguments from the leading Chinese scholars of that time. Western-educated economists (Fan Hong, Wu Bannong) maintained that it is impossible to apply the theory of the multiplier to the conditions of planned economy and this concept cannot be detached from the general framework of the “bourgeois economic theory” of Keynesianism; similarly the adoption of marginal analysis will conflict with the concept of labour theory of value and finally lead to the negation of Marxist political economy. The last section of the paper traces the impact of the 1957 debates upon the development of economics in China during the period of reforms. I argue that successful re-introduction of Western economics was assisted by earlier experience of examination of its applicability in Chinese setting.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.