ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Adam Smith and International Trade: Between the Division of Labour and the Natural Order of Progress
Author: Schumacher Reinhard
There are two seemingly opposing forces in Smith’s writings about foreign trade. A central point of Smith’s argumentation is that foreign trade is beneficial for each country. However, he is contradictory about the question how a poor nation develops in comparison to a rich nation. On the hand, he embeds foreign trade in his concept of the division of labour, which leads to the conclusion that a rich country is able to extend its leads over a poor country. There is a self-enforcing backwardness of the poor country. This is derived from the former books of Smith’s Wealth of Nations. Many have argued that this is a central conclusion of Smith’s trade theory. However, on the other hand, there exists another argument which Smith considers in the latter part of the WN. Here, Smith argues that there exists a natural order of progress. A country will only participate in international trade after its agriculture and industry developed to a certain stage. Each country will eventually reach a final state or a state of stagnation. This includes that poor countries will finally catch up with rich countries. Smith himself does not give a definite solution of this contradiction, namely if there is a divergence or a convergence between rich and poor countries, and how this divergence or convergence is influenced by international trade. Rather, he refrains from any clear conclusion on how poor countries will evolve relative to rich countries. This paper tries to historically reconstruct Smith’s ideas of foreign trade, with a main focus on the development of poor and rich countries. It will be shown which ideas influenced Smith and how he came to the two seemingly contradictory developments. In this context, the “poor country – rich country” debate between David Hume and Josiah Tucker will be considered, which also dealt with the question how Scotland could catch up economically with England. An additionally influence on Smith that will be examined in this context is the growth and decay theory, which was a widespread assumption during Smith’s lifetime. As a result, it should be shown how contemporary ideas influenced Smith’s arguments on international trade. The development of Smith’s ideas will be reconstructed by comparing the Early Draft of the Wealth of Nations with the final version and it will be examined if and how both seemingly opposing statements can be unified.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)