ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The creation of the modern retail market: economic theory, business interests and economic policy-making in the evolution of the 1964 Resale Prices Act
Author: Mercer Helen
Between 1960 and 1964 a battle of ideas was fought out between P.W.S.Andrews and Basil Yamey. The former was an industrial economist, who latterly became professor of Economics at Oxford. In 1960, with Frank Friday, an executive of EMI, he wrote a pamphlet arguing against the abolition of resale price maintenance (RPM) with the economic arguments heavily based on Andrews’ theory of competitive oligopoly. Basil Yamey was a professional economist who wrote one of the most influential papers published by the IEA – a critique of resale price maintenance published also in 1960. The three men then began a war of words with successive editions of Yamey’s pamphlet and additional articles by Friday. It was Yamey’s approach which found favour with Ministers and civil servants to justify abolition four years later. The paper will explain the basis of the dispute between Yamey and Andrews . It puts their ideas into the historical context of the way RPM was operating in Britain at the time, and places them in the long-standing debate on the nature of retail markets first developed by Alfred Marshall. The paper also analyses whose predictions as to the effects of abolition were to prove more accurate, arguing that Andrews was proved correct on several counts, both fairly immediately and in the longer term. Finally, the paper considers the way the economic arguments were handled within government, both by civil servants and Ministers to show that Yamey’s articles provided justification for a policy which had already been agreed, and Yamey’s IEA pamphlet was highly effective in neutralising opposition, even from well-organised private firms and associations and from the Co-operative movement. The paper would fit well into a session indicated in one of the questions: “Who has the greatest influence on the public and policy-makers during great debates about, for instance, the repeal of the Corn Laws or the introduction of the Euro?” I have argued elsewhere that the abolition of RPM bears comparison for its effects on the relationship between retailers and suppliers to the significance of the repeal of the Corn Laws.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)