ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Learning how to Change the World: the Role of Performativity in the General Equilibrium Theory
Author: Boldyrev Ivan, Ushakov Alexey


Arrow-Debreu general equilibrium model has been since its creation a cornerstone of rigorous theoretical modeling in economics. But the questions of its epistemic status received only partial treatment in the literature. It is particularly important since general equilibrium theory, of which the AD model is the most important part, has been for a long time the generic intellectual construction of neoclassical economics and in that sense got a paradigmatic standing. Clarifying various aspects of the AD model may help in addressing more general questions on the nature and various functions of theoretical models in economic theory. We propose to treat the AD model as a specific knowledge machine (Cartwright 1999) that had various explanatory, normative, and technological/pragmatic aspects. The concept of knowledge involves looking at what epistemic “surplus value” is gained from building the model and working with it. In particular, we ask how the model teaches us and can be put to use if one wants to get both a theoretical and a pragmatic insight in the functioning of real economies. Whereas the AD model is often subjected to harsh criticism precisely with respect to its knowledge claims, it is still interesting to distinguish between its particular functions and aspects and to investigate their complex interplay in order to capture more fully the conceptual motivations common to the much of the contemporary economics profession. We analyze this basing on the work of Leonid Hurwicz and trying to link his socialist concerns, his interest in general equilibrium theory, and his subsequent work in mechanism design. The lesson we draw from this analysis is that in assessing economic models and analyzing what sort of knowledge they provide one has to take into consideration their technological potential. Put it differently, apart from the questions: What does the model explain? and What normative view does the model convey? we have to ask another question: What implicit and explicit mechanisms are provided/implied by the model in order to modify economic reality and to mutually stabilize its own account and its subject-matter? What performative (MacKenzie 2006) message, if any, may be distinguished within the model? We claim that this performative aspect is an intrinsic part of the knowledge produced by the model as a knowledge machine.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.