ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: 'On the whole things were quiet.'
Author: Schoorl Evert, Tieben Bert
Schumpeter (1954) has drawn a picture of Dutch economics 1870-1914 in which N.G. Pierson is the personification of a smooth transition from classical to Austrian economics. He has not identified a true Historical School in the Netherlands, or individuals deserving the label of historical economist. In this paper we examine this thesis against the background of the institutional setting of Dutch (academic) economics. It is true that N.G. Pierson fulfilled an important role as the early critical commentator of Roscher and other Historical School protagonists. But there certainly was a lively discussion of the historical approach, not only among the academic economists and in professional journals, but also in more popular and general periodicals and even in parliamentary discussions. Our paper shall revive the key figures of this debate and their arguments pro and con German historicism in economic textbooks, professional and general journals, and policy debates. These sources indicate that in Dutch academic circles the Historical school was the subject of much more debate and controversy than is generally assumed. Of specific concern to our paper is the impact of the political climate on the acceptance of historicism as an economic doctrine. Characteristic of the Dutch political climate in the period under study is the rise of confessional parties of protestant and Roman catholic denomination, which challenged the traditional dominance of the liberal politicians. The ideas of the German historical school provided a source of inspiration for this goal. In a similar manner the rise of socialism provided ammunition to a critical debate about the meaning and relevance of the Historical school. Our provisional conclusion is that in the Netherlands, on the whole things were not altogether so quiet as Schumpeter stated. In academic economics a fairly smooth transition took place from classical economics to marginalist, Marshallian, and Austrian economics. But in public and parliamentary discussions, the Historical School received a warmer appraisal. Dutch economists always had an open eye for the theoretical advancements of the members of the Historical school, who were greatly valued on their own merit. For Dutch economists the Methodenstreit had been a storm in a glass of water. They continued to read and apply the basic tenets of German historicism until well into the twentieth century.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)