ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Why ‘second generation’ classical British economists supported colonisation ?
Author: CLEMENT Alain


During the period from 1815 to 1870, the United Kingdom was the leading naval power in the world. In 1830, the British Empire possessed 90% of the 8.2 million km2 of land colonized by Europe and controlled 90% of the 205 million inhabitants populating that land (Etemad 2005). From 1830 to 1880, the British colonial advance would concern Canada, Australia, the African continent and New Zealand, later followed by India, which would go on to become the greatest of all the colonies. The adoption of free trade policy in 1846 and the subsequent abolition of the Navigation Acts in 1849 and of preferential customs treatment (namely in favour of colonial sugar) in 1854 launched the era of the free trade empire. During this free trade period, the Empire accounted for an average of 32.9% of British exports and 21.9% British of imports (1859-1861 figures). Under these circumstances, the economists engaged in public debate would come to question the very existence of the colonies. A number of topics would be discussed. The first debate pertained to the issue of demography, and specifically emigration to the colonies used as a safety valve for the Crown in contending with high population growth. The second subject concerned the opportunity afforded by the colonies as a solution to declining returns on investments. These two topics thus revolved around the role of the colonies as a means to resolve the United Kingdom’s internal economic and social problems. A second series of questions addressed matters of efficiency, particularly the economic efficiency of colonization as experienced by colonized peoples: could colonization represent an instrument that would serve the development of these supposedly “backward” countries? After an approximate assessment – without taking account of the effects most difficult to measure – most economists considered the cost of colonization to be far greater than its expected gains. Economists then asked whether the colonial enterprise was in fact of any benefit to the home country. Given this context, some would mention the civilizing mission as a driving force for colonization. A third debate would examine the terms of of colonization and its methods of governance. In particular, in respect of settlement colonies like Australia and New Zealand, settlement projects that were chiefly attributable to Wakefield and Wilmot-Horton would attract the attention classical economists and inspire debates that would yield a wealth of proposals. Our text will provide a summary review of the classic arguments that united or opposed the leading classical economists, based on the corpus of economic writings from that period, namely those of Ricardo, Malthus, J. Mill, J.S. Mill, Senior, J.R. McCulloch, Torrens and Scrope, and will then examine the compatibility of their arguments with the liberal economic ideas that they advocated. The central question raised was precisely the compatibility between colonialism and liberalism: can one be a liberal and at the same time defend colonialism? Was there a segment of liberal thought better placed to approve of colonial expansion? What would be the terms of colonisation most in alignment with liberal ideology? In other words, was the colonial question another source of division amongst liberals?

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.