ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: What was the issue in the land-bank controversy?
Author: Ito Seiichiro


In 1694, the year of the foundation of the Bank of England, John Briscoe presented his idea of a land-bank in his well-known pamphlet, A discourse on the late funds, which turned out to be the announcement of the launch of the so-called land-bank controversy lasting several years producing literally uncountable numbers of pamphlets. The realisation of Briscoe’s idea came in the next year with the project of the National Land Bank, though it would end up a failure. Examining the controversy this land-bank project triggered may lead to the conclusion that as a fund of credit land was unrealistic and impractical in comparison with money and that this controversy revealed the difficulty and incoherence of the idea of a land-bank itself. This was how land-bank projects in this period have been understood by historians such as J. K. Horsefield (1960). However, re-examining the pamphlets and reconsidering the arguments in them make it possible to find another story. What projectors struggled for was verification of their own honours and honesty, which were supposed to prove the reliability of their projects and then benefit as its result. This is explained by the projectors’ persistence in claiming their authorship of the idea of project. The question about whose project was original was the issue about which projectors, such as Briscoe, J. Asgill, N. Barbon, and H. Chamberlen, were strongly concerned. The rivalry between ‘monied-men’ and ‘landed-men’ was the framework which was exploited by the Briscoe side, who insisted that the fund of the bank should be mainly land, to blame the plagiarism and distortion of the original design done by ‘monied men’, who argued that the principal content of the fund must be money. This rivalry was not the one between two economic interests. The social framework in which the land-bank projectors were struggling was not necessarily fit for the post-Financial Revolution picture, where the nation was split into those two economic interests over who should pay the interest of public debt. What was at the top of the list for the land-bank projectors was neither the simply economic benefit nor the political interest but the reliability and feasibility of the project.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.