ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Adam Smith’s ‘Nature’—Stoic or Aristotelian?
Author: ANDREWS David


It has long been accepted that Adam Smith’s thought was decisively influenced by Stoic philosophy. D.D. Raphael and A.L. Macfie in their influential introduction to the authoritative 1976 Glasgow edition of Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments [1859] are representative in arguing that Stoic thought was among the most important factors shaping Smith’s ethics and political economy. One pillar of the argument that Smith’s economic theory was influenced by Stoicism is the claim that the Stoic doctrine of the harmonious order of nature can be seen in Smith’s “system of natural liberty”, that the order of the Stoic doctrine is analogous to the order of Smith’s system. From Smith’s claim that “the Stoics, whose opinions were, in all the different parts of philosophy, either the same with, or very nearly allied to those of Aristotle and Plato, though often disguised in very different language” (ALM 9), Eric Schliesser draws the reasonable conclusion: “We can debate the accuracy of Smith’s assessment, but it follows that we have to be cautious in attributing to Smith a Stoic viewpoint if a Platonic or Aristotelian source is just as likely” (2008: 570-71). I suggest that with respect to nature, this caution has been absent, and the differences among Plato, Aristotle and the Stoics have not been clarified. While there is order in Smith’s “system,” it is misleading to describe it as Stoic because it does not possess the characteristics that distinguish the Stoic understanding of nature from Aristotle’s. It is not universally harmonious or normatively optimal, but involves genuine conflicts of interest. Once we distinguish between Aristotelian and Stoic understandings of natural order as Smith did, an examination of Smith’s writings suggests that the order of nature in Smith’s thought bears a strong resemblance to the order of living sublunary nature as described by Aristotle.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.