ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The Merits of Merit Wants
Author: STURN Richard
Merit wants are a multi-faceted concept cutting through a complex array of problems. Those problems are associated with different levels of anal-ysis. Merit wants are not a normatively empty box, as they were occa-sionally called (McLure 1968). They can be seen as shorthand expression for respectable and important concerns, concerns which are particularly important in the context of theoretical frameworks taking human agency seriously as a foundational ingredient of evaluation and explanation of market outcomes, institutions, and social states. This paper deals with the question, Why are merit wants not a firmly established part of modern normative economics, given that simplifying, but still meaningful concepts are in principle suitable as the starting point of research programs? I discuss the following conjecture: The ambiguous status of this concept could be caused by the excessive complexity lurk-ing in the background of the variety of interpretations (cf. Andel 1984, Head 1991, Musgrave 1987 and ver Eecke 2007)? The fragmented dis-cussions include various aspects of - custodial choices, - frame/context dependent and endogenous preferences, - “psychic” externalities, other-regarding and expressive preferences, - concepts of multiple selves and higher order preferences, - communal preferences and social choice, - ethical values and conceptions of well-being/distributive justice invoking specific goods. In order to provide some structure, I will sketch the three levels of merit wants discussions since Musgrave’s seminal contributions (1956/57 and 1959). Using that three-level scheme as interpretive background, sections 3 and 4 provide a selective history of ideas related to merit wants. Section 3 deals with the pre-history of merit wants, while section 4 offers some remarks on the history of merit wants since Musgrave (1956/57). The final section expands on some aspects of merit wants issues related to the level of collective choice.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)