ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The Enlightenment Idea of Improvement and its Discontents: The Case of Orkney in the Eighteenth Century
Author: Furuya Hiroyuki
The aim of this paper is to examine an economic debate that took place in the context of the Pundlar Process (1733–59), a bitterly-fought court case contested between the Earl of Morton, who was an overlord of Orkney and Shetland, and local lairds. This paper is focused on two contemporary documents that attempted to contribute to the lairds as plaintiffs and to Morton as the defendant, respectively: James Mackenzie’s The General Grievances and Oppression of the Isles of Orkney and Shetland (Edinburgh, 1750), and Thomas Hepburn’s A Letter to a Gentleman from his Friend in Orkney, containing the True Causes of the Poverty of that Country (London, 1760). This paper seeks to illuminate the contrasts revealed during the Age of Enlightenment in Scotland by focusing on the conflict between those who tried to promote ‘improvement’ in order to adapt the economy to accelerating competition as trade expanded after the Union of England and Scotland in 1707, and those in the traditional, local communities who sought out alternative ways to accommodate themselves to this change. It is possible to regard Hepburn as possessing certain characteristics held among Scottish Enlightenment thinkers such as Hume and Smith, for instance in the consistent endorsement of the Union of 1707 and in the analysis of the consequent growth of the market economy as a powerful and effective means to increase wealth and solve the real problems of finance and poverty. The Orkney lairds – and Mackenzie, their legal representative – on the other hand, resisted the Enlightenment idea of ‘improvements’ introduced and carried out by Morton. This paper concludes that the truth is far more complicated, and that the local lairds were not always against the improvement of their own estates. The Orkney lairds seemed to clash with the mainland-born aristocrat not because they were against improvement but because they sought to pursue improvement in their local communities in their own way in order to themselves adapt to the expanding market economy made possible under the Union. Practical improvers in the country disdained the ‘improving’ writers of the Enlightenment, who in their view neglected the fact that the real improvement had happened long before.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)