ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: “Quorum pars magna fui”: Notes on Marx’s reading of Cantillon
Author: Ananyin Oleg
Oleg Ananyin “Higher School of Economics”, National Research University, Moscow Russia “Quorum pars magna fui”: Notes on Marx’s reading of Cantillon Abstract Since rediscovery of Richard Cantillon by W.S. Jevons in 1881 his extraordinary role in the shaping of economic theory was recognized many times by many authors. But contrary to these declarations his place in the history of economic science is still far from being indispensable, unlike those of Adam Smith, Karl Marx, Karl Menger, or John M. Keynes. One possible explanation of this contradiction is that later, i.e. post-Jevonian assessments of Cantillon were constrained by established historiographical routines, while the actor to be introduced into the story was of such range that the whole story had to be rewritten. The paper does not pretend to provide such a new story. Its ambition is to suggest a case study of an alternative interpretation of Cantillon’s contribution coming from Karl Marx known to be a close and interested observer of emerging science of political economy, not to be suspected of dependence upon later historiographical routines. The author of the first English translation of Cantillon’s “Essay” (1931) Henry Higgs supplied his edition with a list of earlier writers who had references to the previous editions. Although XIX century was represented by three titles only in this list (reprints excluded), Marx was missing from it. Yet Marx did know Cantillon. References to the “Essay” could be found in the 1st and the 3d volumes of “Das Kapital”, in Marx’s chapter in Engels’s “Anti-During”, as well as in his manuscripts. Already these references are indicative of the general attitude to Cantillon, as well as of specific themes which attracted Marx’s attention. His general attitude is most vividly expressed in the manuscript of the second volume of “Das Kapital” from 1868-69, where Marx commented on often cited Marquis de Mirabeau’s phrase about three great discoveries of humankind, with “Tableau économique” as one of them, with Virgil’s lament from the Aeneid: “About ‘Tableau économique’, as well as about physiocrats in general Cantillon could say: ‘Quorum pars magna fui.’”. It is now possible to shed some new light upon the background of Marx’s comments on Cantillon. Due to international MEGA project publishing complete edition of texts by Marx and Engels it became known that Marx’s excerpts from Cantillon had survived, and that they are much more extended than available fragments could suggest. Based upon analysis of these excerpts as well as published texts, the paper is aiming to reconstruct Marx’s vision of Cantillon as a key figure in shaping political economy, and to compare it with some competing interpretations of his place in intellectual history. This analysis is supported with a review of an early Marxian assessment of Cantillon in the paper from 1927 by a Soviet economist Alexandra Eidelnant.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)