ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Economic interdependencies and political conflict: the case of taxation in eighteenth-century French and British economic thought
Author: Cardinale Ivano, Coffman DMaris


Session: Historical Political Economy Economic interdependencies and political conflict: the case of taxation in eighteenth-century French and British economic thought Authors: Ivano Cardinale, D'Maris Coffman Structural economic analysis has represented economic systems as structures of economic interdependencies among productive sectors (Quesnay, 1972 [1759]; Leontief, 1941; Pasinetti, 1981). Such representation can be used as a heuristic for the structure of economic interest of a given society, which can help uncover the configuration of political interests and the relative positions of the groups that hold those interests. The method used to explore the interdependencies between the economic and political domains is that of multi-level correspondences between economic sectors and interest groups (Quesnay, 1972 [1759]; Hobson, 1902). Any structural configuration of the economy leaves space for conflict between interest groups, which is nonetheless bounded by the necessity to maintain the economic system viable. This approach provides a vantage point to understand both contemporary and historical political-economic processes. A particular compelling instance of this involves debates about the political economy of taxation in eighteenth-century France and Britain. Much contemporary economic writing, including that of those who are often called Mercantilists and those who are classified as Physiocrats, was concerned with how to maximize tax revenues without impairing either agricultural production or the growing commodity economies. For Quesnay, Mirabeau, Turgot and their contemporaries, just as for those writing from across the channel such as Davenant, Hume and Smith, the challenge was to impose taxation in a way that satisfied competing interest groups (land owners, great merchants, and still powerful leading artisans) without damaging the overall productive capacity of the kingdom. British debates about excise taxation of beer and ale turned on whether or not the duty would be shifted backwards onto the landowner (in the form of lower prices paid for the agricultural products used in the production of excisable liquors) forwards onto the consumer (in the form of higher retail prices), or capitalised by the manufacturers. The collapse of John Law’s scheme in France, the Excise Crisis of 1733 in Britain, and the Massachusetts Excise Crisis of 1754, and the financial crises in Britain and France in the wake of the Seven Years War are each illustrative of these dynamics. The authors plan to use these examples to show the power of their approach for unpacking debates about the eighteenth-century fiscal-military state and for historical political economy more generally.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.