ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Business Practice in Early Transnationalization: Controversial Views on Trade Companies
Author: TRAUTWEIN Hans-Michael
The modern term “transnationalization” refers to economic, social and legal relations that dissolve traditional boundaries of nation states, essentially by initiatives of non-state agents. It is used for describing the increasing degree of vertically integrated production in transnational corporations or supply chains, for global financial networks and other new types of cross-border relations. However, the expansion of trade, investment and finance beyond the confines of territorial sovereignty is not an entirely new phenomenon. It was also constitutive for the “modern world system” in which nation states and markets evolved together between the 16th and 19th centuries. Trade companies, both chartered and unchartered, played a key role in this evolution, but their role has been assessed quite differently in the history of economic thought. The differences in the views on trade companies are largely congruent with Turgot’s distinction between the perspectives of political economy on the one hand, and business & management skills on the other. In a political economy perspective that was highly critical towards the "mercantile system", Adam Smith (1776) discussed the business practices of trade companies and their effects on the wealth of nations, especially in regard of the Dutch and British East India Companies. He argued that their monopolies of trade lead to excessively high prices and misallocation of capital, that joint monopolies of trade and coercive powers lead to bad political governance, and that the generic conflicts between agents and principals in joint stock companies are exacerbated by spatial separation. Smith’s views received qualified support from James Mill (1817), Karl Marx (1867) and other writers in political economy, who largely set their focus on processes of colonialization, but they were also criticized within that perspective, for example, by Friedrich List (1841), Paul Leroy-Beaulieu (1882) and Alfred Marshall (1920). Writers in historicist traditions frequently took up mercantilist views, which conceptualized political economy in terms of a “unified science of trade”, and some authors, such as Werner Sombart (1902), described the business practices of trade companies more distinctly from a business & management perspective. The proposed paper discusses these different views and relates them to their historical backgrounds as well as to institutionalist concepts in modern literatures. [In the case of difficulties with downloading this paper, it is also available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2234953]
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)