ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: On open identity; otherness, distance and self-command; Smith and the view of justice
Author: VAGGI Gianni


Since John Rawls Theory of Justice in 1971 a lot of debates have taken place the appropriate procedures and rules for the organization of social discourse among people, countries, societies. In his 2009 The Idea of Justice Sen adds a partially different, perhaps complementary, point of view, contrasting his view of open impartiality to Rawls closed one. The latter notion refers to impartiality inside a group of people sharing similar values, it is an intra-societal impartiality; the first concept indicates inter-societal relationships since it strives for the involvement of the viewpoints of others. Needles to say the terminology derives from Smith’s impartial spectator metaphor. The question is: how can modern societies implement the open impartiality approach? How can they progress on the impartial arbitration of different perspectives on what is right and what is wrong? Making use of Smith’s contribution this paper indicates a possible strategy in this direction. Three main steps are envisaged. First step. Otherness; society is made of many different people and characters, but there are also many societies in the world: that is to say: a cosmopolitan view is inevitable, and this implies accepting differences. In the paper presented at St. Petersburg Sara Stefanini and myself have highlighted the contribution of the Italian philosopher Pareyson (1954), who wants to promote the value of respecting otherness and it aims at finding the way to help equivalent people and groups of people to feed their differences one on the others. Second step. Distance and trust. Distance among people, classes and societies is a fact, a starting point. How to reduce this distance? How to create trust among different focal groups. Pareyson describes truth as inexhaustible and accessible only by each singular perspective. Thus every man becomes a particular source of truth and moral balance; all the more so when the same values are shared by a group of people. How can different points of view lead to mutual trust? Markets, perhaps we should say trade and commerce, are powerful institutions through which people communicate. Do they necessarily reduce distance? Could they in some cases increase it? The same is true for general rules of law, or agreed procedure a là Rawls, or external, to focal groups, international(even judiciary) bodies. Third step. All the above accepted perhaps there s still need for facing in a direct way the issue of the communication of different judgments in order to build trust. Imagination and sympathy are important ways for this relationship to lead to trustable linkages. But they can be greatly helped by another extremely important element which has not yet been fully recognized: truth as sincerity, everyone's ability to communicate the personal truth. In general the higher the degree of transparency the more likely is to achieve a social compact based on a good degree of trust. Sincerity builds on self-command. Sympathy, imagination and self-command make sincerity and transparency a workable strategy in the process of playing the game of inter-societal impartiality. Each individual (and group) has many identities, but in this communication of views the blend of original identity can evolve. Identities are not given once for all, they do change in a dynamic way. The Us-The Others scheme, which we presented last year is based on the use of sincerity and on the conscious exercise of self command. are essential components to try to build a society based on open identity.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.