ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The Economist who Mistook his Model for a Market
Author: Rotheim Roy
The Economist who Mistook his Model for a Market (abstract) Roy J. Rotheim Skidmore College New York The question posed to me for my endnote talk at the Roskilde/Dijon Post Keynesian conference in 2011 was whether we can expect Post Keynesian economics to be embraced and taught in mainstream academia? If ever there were a compelling case for Post Keynesian economics in both theory and policy it would be now in light of the anemic recovery in the global recession of 2007-2009 and the levels of high unemployment that have persisted long after we passed out of that recession. Interventionist policies during that recession were, however, too late and too little hampered by an antipathy among policy makers toward such policies. At one level removed there was also a corresponding economic mainstream view based on closed system thinking -- predicated on the impossibility of economic fluctuations for the economy as a whole -- that admitted to no theoretical basis for lending support to these policies. In the place of expansionary fiscal and monetary policies that were put into force we are now seeing a call for the return to economic growth by the traditional policies of fiscal austerity and monetary restraint. The persistently high and prolonged unemployment world-wide is deemed to be structural, not remediable by interventionist monetary or fiscal policies. Post Keynesian concerns about failures of effective demand in an open-system framework, involuntary unemployment (beyond the control of the atomistic individual of the mainstream), large and growing inequalities in income and wealth (abhorrent in their own right and a significant cause of the paucity of aggregate demand), and a preponderance of speculation and financial circulation over enterprise and industrial circulation are no longer taken seriously (if they ever were). Mainstream macroeconomics has redirected its attention toward fending off their interventionist critics, defaulting to the hydraulics of the quantity theory of money (the voices of the inflation hawks becoming louder by the day) with the rallying cry that the long-run consequences of myopic sustained low short-term interest rate targets and various forms of quantitative easing could portend inflationary disaster -- with the appropriate lag, of course. Budget deficits and sovereign debt crises are the current boogie-men held with great conviction to be crowding out more efficient private sector spending. Large deficits, it is believed, will encourage higher inflation expectations and therefore higher nominal and real interest rates or will invoke Ricardian Equivalence effects causing individuals to curtail current consumption in favor of increased current saving (out of what income?) so that they will be able to pay the higher taxes that will surely be imposed in the future to cover the higher deficits today (See Dow, 2012, pp. 80-81). It is business as usual in the teaching of economics beginning and ending with the relative market consequences of individual choices of products and productive processes framed in deductivist mathematical models (see Lawson, 2012a, p. 10). One should not be surprised that the call for a greater plurality in the teaching of economics, especially Post Keynesian economics, has fallen on deaf ears. There is neither an acknowledgment let alone a comprehension of true Keynesian and Post Keynesian perspectives. What is understood to be ‘Keynesian’ economics by the mainstream focuses on imperfect information and other obstructions and intrusions into the conventional market model. Returns to full employment are seen as the result of stickiness of relative wages and prices and other structural mismatches in the labor and goods markets. Alleviate the frictions and imperfections in those markets, allow for appropriate time for readjustment, and all will be well in theory and policy. In that case, Keynesian economics (as J.R. Hicks asserted so persuasively 75 years ago) reduces to nothing more than a variant of the traditional mainstream perspective: "Macroeconomics is redundant," is how Chick voiced it so well (1998, p. 1863). Genuine Post Keynesian economics is neither taken seriously nor given the slightest degree of legitimization in mainstream economics departments. Mainstream economics is the only standard by which economists are measured; it is the only body of work by which the discipline is defined and understood. One is taught only mainstream economics in graduate school and the top journals contain only articles that require models formulated around mainstream reasoning. At a deeper level, the mainstream is articulated and disseminated in such a way that its language and its visual representations make imperceptible the types of fundamental frameworks on which a Keynes/Post Keynesian analysis are founded (see Kurtz, 2010, p. 12 and Rotheim 2006). In the current essay I focus on a few of the points that address why mainstream economics has built an impenetrable wall around itself such that they cannot envision, let alone take seriously, any alternative economic perspective beyond their own. It is in this way that I affirm my assertion that the likelihood of Post Keynesian economics being accepted into the corpus of teaching in the academy is near impossible. In the next section I will address what I see to be the fundamental deductivist element of the mainstream project: confusing metaphors in space with processes in time, to employ the picture painted by Joan Robinson (1953). The mainstream project perceives and operates in a metaphor of space, giving life (timeful conceptualizations) to points in space that are timeless and lifeless. Emerging from these timeless conceptualizations is a language of spatial metaphors that reflects what Herbert Marcuse called 'functionalised language'. These I will address in the section to follow. From there I shall give examples of how these timeless conceptualizations lead to perceptions and policies that reinforce the mainstream deductivist project, focusing on question of unemployment as it is perceived by the mainstream.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)