ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Duty to work, lieutenancy and growth in the thought of John Calvin
Author: Bauer Caroline


This article examines the relation which John Calvin, reformer in Geneva from 1536 to his death in 1564, introduces between the duty to work and the necessity of pursuing the enrichment of the society. The analysis is based on a pattern in Calvin’s thought called here duty of lieutenancy. This duty is defined in “The Institution of Christian Religion” as a duty to manage the goods as a deposit of God, for which the man will have to answer for. We highlight that it means entering through work a particular collaboration with God, justifying to look for prosperity and social justice, and therefore to promote enrichment. This analysis opposes in several points to Weber’s argumentation on later Calvinism in “The protestant Ethic and the spirit of capitalism”. It leads to contest Weber’s assimilation of vocation to profession and the centrality of the argument of predestination as a psychological motivation to work. Likewise if Calvin’s interpretation of work justifies the search for enrichment, the end of economic activities can’t be accumulation, but the pursuit of social utility. In the first part, we show how is built the justification of work according to the duty of lieutenancy. The prosperity appears as a mark of communion with God. Yet this promise of prosperity is associated with the idea of increase, and does commit man to participate through work to God’s plan. In second part, we analyze the consequences of the obligation of lieutenancy on the sense granted by Calvin to work. A dynamic understanding of the world is put forward, work being then the means to welcome God's creative power and to give it at the disposal of men. We compare the calvinian positions with some described by Weber. The third part examines how work can lead, according to the lieutenancy, to a continuous and rational search for enrichment of the society. We distinguish the prosperity according to Calvin from individual enrichment and, with the support of the principal-agent model, we analyze how lieutenancy implies the maximization of collective enrichment. We discuss then the weberian justification of the search for gain. We bring out a Calvin's specific contribution on the sense of work, and propose another interpretation of the way a religious consciousness is able to favor economic dynamism.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.