ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Professor De Vroey on Hicks’s recantation of the temporary general equilibrium method
Author: Dvoskin Ariel, Trabucchi Paolo
Among the economists who, in order to study value and distribution, first introduced the notion of temporary (or intertemporal) equilibrium — the notion on which orthodox theory is based at present —, J.R. Hicks, with his Value and Capital (1939), has probably been the most influential. What, with few notable exceptions coming from outside the orthodox theory (e.g. Petri, 1991), has gone practically unnoticed is Hicks’ subsequent (1956, 1965) recantation of that method. This situation appears to reflect the implicit opinion, which orthodox economists must have shared, according to which the reasons adduced by Hicks to question the validity of the new method are not sound or especially relevant. A particular version of this opinion has recently been explicitly put forward by M. De Vroey (2006). It is De Vroey’s contention that ‘Hicks should not have recanted his earlier [1939] position’. In particular, De Vroey argues that Hicks’s self-criticisms mainly turn around the question of the relatively low speed of adjustment of prices to their equilibrium values, whereas the notion of temporary (or intertemporal) equilibrium, when correctly understood, should be applied only to an otherwise unspecified ‘logical time’. We claim on the contrary that, once it is acknowledged that, differently from what De Vroey appears to believe, no alternative route besides the one represented by the temporary (or intertemporal) equilibrium method lay open in front of Hicks within the orthodox theory on account of the difficulties this theory has to face in the treatment of capital as a factor of production, the inconsistencies De Vroey correctly pins down in Hicks’s own retrospective opinion on that method should not be interpreted merely as the expression of his failure to understand the true nature of the method he had contributed to build, as the expression of his perception of the deeper difficulties that beset that method and of the dilemma in which orthodox economists find themselves after the abandonment of the traditional notion of equilibrium.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)