ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: On Robinson, Porter, and the industrial organization view
Author: Jacobsen Lowell
This paper builds on the author's recent EJHET article, "On Robinson, Penrose, and the resource based view of strategy", which focuses on the neglected and not insignificant influence of Austin Robinson on Edith Penrose and her widely-recognised pioneering work with respect to the resource-based view of strategy. In particular, this paper turns to exploring Robinson's anticipation of Michael Porter's seminar work with respect to the industrial organization view of strategy which has been hitherto largely overlooked. Porter (1981, p. 509) observed that many industrial organization economists and strategy researchers for many years acted like 'ships passing in the night' as they 'viewed each other with suspicion' despite 'much promise for cross-fertilization'. Such 'suspicion' and independence are attributed to a contrast in perspectives, whereby practitioners and teachers of strategy are concerned with the achievement of a firm's competitive advantage whereas IO economists are generally concerned with the promotion of public welfare whereby monopolies or firms with inordinate market power are subject to government intervention or even regulation. Nevertheless, the traditional Bain/Mason structure-conduct-performance paradigm of industrial organization with its roots in the 1930s, despite its static perspective and public policy focus, offered strategy a systematic framework for analysing competition within the industry context. To be sure, Porter more than anyone else reduced the gap between industrial organization and strategy as his work in the 1970s and 1980s primarily established the industrial organization view of strategy. Robinson very much shared Porter's perspective of utilising the analytical tools of industrial economics to explain as well as to promote the success of firms within an evolving, though stable, industry structure. In his classic volume, The Structure of Competitive Industry, first published in 1931, Robinson offers his own five forces framework in which managers can systematically assess the internal and external environments in order to determine their firm's most competitive position and 'optimal size(s)'. Indeed, this paper examines the connections between the frameworks of Porter and Robinson. Whilst this paper intends to provide at least a heightened appreciation for the industrial economics of Austin Robinson (and what Shove praised as 'real economics') furthermore, it might deepen the intellectual roots of strategy, a relatively young interdisciplinary field. As Schumpeter (1954, p. 13) reminds, a proper understanding of a subject requires 'an adequate command of historical facts and an adequate amount of historical sense'.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)