ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The powerful mix of pride and greed: the Mandevillean legacy in Hume and Rousseau
Author: Verburg Rudi


In the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries social order, commerce and progress are the hot topics of debate. In these debates authors started to emphasize the positive social function of vanity and greed; passions that had earlier been qualified as deadly sins. The rise of such ideas was closely connected with the emergence of the large, impersonal, commercial society, in which there was no longer a direct relationship between motives and intentions on the one hand and consequences of behavior on the other. The debates not only concerned the question of the selfish or social nature of man but also the relation between individual passions and motives and collective outcomes. How to get individuals with all their conflicting passions and desires to co-operate and realize advantages for the good of all; a positive-sum society? Remarkably, greed and vanity were assigned an important role here. This paper first describes how Mandeville constructed a basic model showing the positive social function of greed and vanity. He provoked many by the way he colored the model. Mandeville described society as the product of both destructive and constructive forces; conflict, rule breaking, vices and co-operation, rule following, morality. Next the versions of the model by David Hume and Jean-Jacques Rousseau are discussed. Both authors argue the growing preponderance of one of both forces with the development of society. Choosing differently, Rousseau’s image of commercial society is the pessimistic mirror image of Hume’s optimistic account. These accounts allow us to get an idea of the conditions under which vanity and greed were thought to contribute to co-operation and mutual trust.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.