ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: KEYNES'S GENERAL THEORY, TREATISE ON MONEY AND TRACT ON MONETARY REFORM: DIFFERENT THEORIES, SAME METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH
Author: Carabelli Anna Maria, Cedrini Mario Aldo


Acquaintance with A Treatise on Probability allows readers of The General Theory to grasp the essence of Keynes’s famous definition of economics as a “method rather than a doctrine ... which helps its possessor to draw correct conclusions”. Keynes’s criticism of the classical theory is first and foremost of a methodological nature, and rests upon the introduction of tacit assumptions of independence into the analysis. In Chapter 18 of The General Theory, Keynes makes explicit the assumptions of independence he himself has introduced into the analysis of chapters 1-17, and informs readers about the peculiar character of the notions of cause and independence he has used in constructing his theory. “Cause” and “independence” are related to the concept of “independence for knowledge”, which concerns logical connections between arguments rather than material connections between events. Such logical connections are re-discussed in chapters 19-21, where Keynes allows for probable repercussions between the factors and removes the simplifying assumptions previously introduced. The paper shows that the revolutionary character of the General Theory, both A Tract on Monetary Reform and A Treatise on Money show direct evidence of methodological continuity with it. In the Tract on Monetary Reform, Keynes revisits the traditional formulation of the quantitative theory of money by attacking the illicit introduction of a hypothesis of independence of the quantity of cash in circulation on habits of the public in the use of money and banks’ reserve policies. In the Treatise on Money, the analysis of credit cycles follows a “two-stage” methodology which perfectly parallels the one later used in The General Theory. In the paper, we aim to show that despite radical differences in the theories, which obviously reflect Keynes’s gradual abandonment of the orthodoxy but also the different quaesita of the analyses and changing circumstances, the three treatises are associated by the use of a same methodological approach. This is consistent with Keynes’s definition of economics as a non-demonstrative logic, that is a way of reasoning about the economic material. What Keynes’s theory of economics offers in truth is therefore a method of analysis, one which expressly requires, as the three treatises demonstrate, cooperation on the part of the reader, in the effort to emulate the author in coping with the complexity of the economic material.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.