ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The controversy over international cartels in the League of Nations (1925- 1927). Lessons for the current debate about the regulation of international competition
Author: Chase Christian, Garcí­a Hidalgo José Luis, Palma Martos Luis


Today, few economists doubt the benefits arising from competitive process. The competition allows higher levels of efficiency are achieved by ensuring that consumers benefit from better products at lower prices. One consequence is the fact that over 100 states are endowed institutions specifically dedicated to ensuring the maintenance of effective competition in their domestic markets. However, this consensus is not extrapolated to the international dimension. While most economists believe that competition in global markets yields similar benefits to domestic competition, no agreement has been reached to form an institution for promoting and protecting international competition. In fact, in the last years of the last century, we were about to witness an agreement within the WTO by which international anticompetitive practices would be regulated. However, the lack of international vision due to a national conception of the problems ended truncating the agreement, leaving us to a compromise solution based on convergence and cooperation, and keeping alive the debate on the regulation of international cartels. The current controversy over the regulation of international competition reproduces a similar -though different- situation to which it was in the interwar period. Then, the League of Nations was the institution in charge of economic and political reconstruction of international relations in general, and in Europe in particular. In a specific context, the brightest minds of the time reflected on the regulatory keys that should return the world to the path of prosperity. The economic debate confronted protectionist stances, who conceived cartels as a manifestation of new phase of capitalism aimed at alleviating their instability through the rationalization of industrial production, opposed to supporters of free trade and competition. The French Minister Loucheur represented the first of these positions, while Cassel was who defended free competition more vehemently. In the field of economic ideas, controversy pitted the neoclassical school (competition) and the German historical school (conditional cartelization). The paper that we present offers an analysis of this episode, since we believe that it may reveal some clues to shed some light on the current debate on the desirability of establishing a comprehensive international competition policy.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.