ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Keynes and the International Monetary System: Time for a Tabular Standard
Author: Haas Armin, Jaeger Carlo, Töpfer Klaus, Ussher Leanne


Keynes’s post war vision for the international monetary system is best known from his writings on a proposed International Clearing Union and international reserve currency, which he called Bancor. These were the primary components of the unsuccessful British proposal prior to the July 1944 Bretton Woods Conference. Co-written with colleagues and bureaucrats at the UK Treasury and Bank of England, these proposals were political compromises, which did not necessarily reflect Keynes’s ideal international policy reforms. This paper suggests that in an ideal world, Keynes’s Bancor would have been backed by commodities and gold, under a bimetallic standard, thus creating an international commodity reserve currency, similar to that proposed by Jan Goudriaan, Benjamin Graham, and Frank Graham in the same period, and strongly promoted decades later in the 60s and 70s by Nicholas Kaldor and Albert Hart. We come to this conclusion by considering Keynes’s earlier sole authored international monetary proposals where Keynes argued in three separate cases between 1930 and 1933 for an international reserve currency that would be indexed to a tabular standard in the form of a basket of internationally traded primary commodities; his 1938 paper on public commodity buffer stocks where he argued that primary commodity stores could substitute for gold as UK international reserves; his move away from monetary to fiscal policy as a stimulus for effective demand during a liquidity trap; his Bretton Woods proposal for individual commodity buffer stocks that would inject new money and effective demand into the global system to stabilize the world trade cycle; and his statement in 1944 in the Economic Journal that the Tabular Standard should be a long term visionary goal: “I have no quarrel with a tabular standard as being intrinsically more sensible than gold. My own sympathies have always fallen that way. I hope the world will come to some version of it some time. But … the right way to approach the tabular standard is to evolve a technique and to accustom men's minds to the idea through international buffer stocks. When we have thoroughly mastered the technique of these, which is sufficiently difficult without the further complications of the tabular standard and the oppositions and prejudices which this must overcome, it will be time enough to think again” (Keynes 1944, 429-430).

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.