ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Institutionalism versus Marxism: Are there Grounds for Reconciliation?
Author: Sunal Seckin


A debate between institutional economics and Marxism has been continuing for decades. The critiques of institutional economics on Marxian theory concentrate on peculiarities of individuals (agents) being overlooked due to the overemphasis on laws of motion in (pre)capitalist societies. Moreover, teleology is attributed to Marxist theory while institutional economics is celebrated for embracing evolution. Marxist thinkers, quiet defensively on the other hand, claim that hints of what would be the core of evolutionary economics and institutionalism is existent in Marxism's legacy. Moreover, Marxism puts the emphasis on changing the world and the state it is in, disparaging other schools of thought for not pursuing such an end. A very frequent theme marked in such debates is that the level of analysis, abstraction and detail in Marxist theory and institutionalism do not coincide. While Marxist theory is after some inferences at macro, historic or even systemic level, the scale of analysis in institutionalism is contingent or much closer to micro level. This study is an inquiry for a ground, above which comparing tools, methods, inferences and subjects of these two schools of thought can be possible and just. When considered as a common feature of Marxism and institutionalism, or a transition path from one school of thought to the other rather than as another field of dispute between the two, economic and social evolution becomes a promising candidate for seeking reconciliation. The paper investigates the possibilities and limits of defining a common ground between Marxism and institutionalism above economic and social evolution.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.