ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The Role of the Pons Asinorum Test in Economics: Leslie Stephen versus John Ruskin and the Victorian Effort to Exclude the Amateur “Public Intellectual” from Economics.
Author: Fordham Helen, Moore Gregory
Victorian intellectual life was partly defined by professionals, scientists and academics seeking to use their increasingly specialised and technical knowledge to exclude both second-rate thinkers and literary men of letters from the various disciplinary domains. In the field of political economy this process of exclusion entailed assessing whether or not the second-rate economist and/or man of letters demonstrated knowledge of specific techniques and theorems that amounted to pons asinorum tests. The nature of this struggle between the expert and the amateur is evident in Leslie Stephen’s critiques of the work of John Ruskin after the latter had strayed from the fields of aesthetics and culture to comment upon political economy in a series of narratives between 1860 and 1884. Although Stephen and Ruskin shared a desire to improve Victorian England’s political economy and address the significant social inequities of the day, Stephen objected to Ruskin’s lack of logic and failure to understand the basic pons asinorum techniques and theories that would have qualified him to comment authoritatively on political economy. It is argued that this controversy illuminates the growing professionalization of political economy and illustrates the broader tensions between the amateur and the expert that were to become more pronounced in the 20th century.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


