ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Sraffa’s manuscripts in preparation of Production of Commodities: on some notable diversities compared with the book
Author: Ciccone Roberto
The paper points to some interesting differences which emerge by the comparison of Sraffa’s manuscripts concerning the material of PCMC, dated 1955 to 1959 (?) and strictly relating to the latest phases of preparation of the 1960 book, with what finally appears in the publication. That the stuff included in the book consists of a subset of what we find in those papers is something one could expect as the outcome of the natural process of elimination of what the author (and particularly such a concise writer as Sraffa) may deem to be expository redundancies. However, the gap is evidently bigger than that, in a twofold respect. The book does not include some arguments which, besides being studied in the papers of the fifties, Sraffa had been working on since the beginning of his research on value and distribution. Further, with regard to some of the subjects contained in the book, there are instances of relevant aspects dealt with in the manuscripts which do not appear in the published version, or which the manuscripts treat in a significantly more explicit form than the book does. A case of the first type of diversity, which will be considered in this paper, is what in the manuscripts Sraffa often refers to as ‘Industrial Scheme’, consisting in the possibility of production processes starting continuously in time, with outputs in turn flowing in a continuous manner. Sraffa uses the label just mentioned in opposition to that of ‘Agricultural Scheme’, which he adopts in the papers for the case in which each process of production is taken to start at the beginning, and be completed at the end, of the ‘year’–this being in fact the modality we only find in the book. Instances of the second kind of divergence are several. Among those which will be mentioned and shortly discussed in the present paper, an issue of general character is that in the manuscripts Sraffa is much more explicit than in the book in connecting his approach to that of the classical economists and of Marx; while examples of specific points more extensively treated in the manuscripts concern the distinction between subsistence and surplus shares of the wage when the latter exceeds necessaries, or the grounds on which the value of the national income relative to aggregate means of production could be assumed to be stable in the face of changes in distribution and relative prices.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


