ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Hume, Montesquieu and the Origins of the Specie-Flow Mechanism of Trade Balance Adjustment
Author: Dimand Robert


In "Of the Balance of Trade" in his Political Discourses (1752), the philosopher David Hume famously argued the futility of what Adam Smith later termed "the mercantile system of political economy": a positive balance of trade and specie inflow resulting from interference with trade flows would not last, because the gold and silver inflow would increase money in circulation and raise prices in the home country (and reduce money in circulation and prices in the rest of the world), restoring net exports to equilibrium. Two puzzles attend this well-known essay. Why did the author of A Treatise on Human Nature bother to turn his attention from fundamental problems of epistemology to show that some "consultant administrators and pamphleteers" (as Schumpeter called them) were confused and misguided? Why did Hume first expound the price/specie-flow mechanism of restoration of trade balance equilibrium in a 1749 letter to Montesquieu about the latter's recently-published L'esprit des lois? This paper argues that these two puzzles have the same answer: Hume was responding to a chapter by Montesquieu that claimed some countries could not benefit from international trade because silver would leave them never to return, a chapter that neglected the consequent adjustment of price levels. Hume did not mention the offending chapter, or directly criticize Montesquieu, whom he greatly respected -- instead he included in his comments on Montesquieu's book an exposition of how international trade adjustment would occur. Later commentators on Montesquieu's economics and on the intellectual interaction between Hume and Montesquieu have concentrated on the doux commerce thesis (the civilizing and pacific influence of trade) or on Keynes's citation of Montesquieu as a precursor in his preface to the French translation of The General Theory, but have not remarked on that chapter of L'esprit des lois. I argue that this omission is due to the dependence of studies of Hume as an economist on Eugene Rotwein's 1955 of Hume's Writings on Economics (the AEA Index of Economic Journals, covering journals in English from 1886, found no economics articles on Hume before the review articles on Rotwein). The annotation of the relevant section of Hume's 1749 letter to Montesquieu in Rotwein's 1955 edition and later printings refers to an innocuous and irrelevant single-paragraph chapter by Montesquieu about ports of trade. I believe this to be simply a typographical error in the chapter number, but it was sufficient to misdirect attention.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.