ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Competitive Society in Maffeo Pantaleoni’s Thought. Protectionism and co-operativism as ways to the ‘establishment of total socialism’
Author: Tedesco Luca
The originality of the Italian economist Maffeo Pantaleoni (1857-1924) is due in large part to his attempt, in the last decades of the nineteenth century, to apply the theory of marginalism to the problems of public finance (Contributo alla teoria del riparto delle spese pubbliche (Contribution to the theory of the distribution of public expenditure): 1883). At the beginning of the twentieth century, however, Pantaleoni focused his attention on the issue of the competitive society (Il secolo ventesimo secondo un individualista (The twentieth century according to an individualist): 1900a), which is the subject of this paper. According to Pantaleoni, a competitive society is characterized by the fact that political (and therefore coercive) and market relations develop autonomously, without affecting each other. Historically the maximum implementation of the competitive society was identified by Pantaleoni as having taken place in the early years of the Kingdom of Italy (1861-1876), when the coercive functions of the state were limited to the enforcement of rules of conduct addressed to all citizens and thus allowed the full realization of competition. In the light of this position we can observe a high degree of consistency in the evolution of Pantaleoni’s political attitudes, from the pro-socialist in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century to the pro-nationalist and pro-Fascist of later years. Pantaleoni was in fact persuaded to side with the Socialists in criticising the political economy (especially protectionism) and the restriction of political and civil freedom because, in his view, such policies undermined the foundations on which a genuinely liberal government should be built: namely the adoption of general rules and, conversely, the rejection of discretionary and arbitrary attitudes aimed at special interests. For the same reasons, before and even more after the First World War, Pantaleoni railed against the socialist world (Note in margine della guerra (Notes in the margin of the War): 1917a; Tra le incognite. Problemi suggeriti dalla guerra (Among the unknown. Problems caused by war): 1917b; Politica. Criteri ed eventi (Politics: criteria and events): 1918 and Bolscevismo italiano (Italian Bolshevism): 1922a). In fact, in his opinion, socialism, imposing political prices, that is prices determined through a discriminating procedure instead of on economic grounds, denied the autonomy of the economic and competitive sphere from the political. This was the case of the co-operative societies, supported by the Socialist Party. Only by keeping in mind Pantaleoni’s belief that socialism represented the greatest threat to liberal civilization can we understand the support given by him to Fascism, regarded by him as the last chance to save the vestiges of the liberal system from ‘Bolshevik barbarism’. Luca Tedesco
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


