ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Causality and structure in economic and historical analysis.
Author: Taalbi Josef


Causal inference in historical, complex systems is one of the core methodological issues of the social sciences. The problem is well-known: what are we to make of causal inference when the study object does not allow us to isolate causes and effects in well-controlled and repeatable experiments? To the Swedish economist Johan Ã…kerman, structural analysis, the study of stable economic mechanisms and their evolution, was a prerequisite of causal analysis in historical and complex systems. Thus, the study of history was viewed to be a necessary aspect of delineating causal economic mechanisms. This essay explores this suggestion by reviewing causal ontologies implicit or explicit in economic theory. The Humean notion of causality is contrasted with relational outlooks in which events and processes are already immersed in spatiotemporal structures. The question posed is whether (and if so, under what circumstances) causal analysis can be freed from underlying conceptions of totality and structure. The paper then discusses the ontological status and meaning given to the notion of structure in static equilibrium analysis, game theory and non-linear dynamics and the work of Johan Ã…kerman and the Schumpeter-inspired Swedish school of structural analysis. An emerging issue is whether structural change is understood as driven endogenously, or if such changes must be imposed as being exogenous. It is argued that empirical structural analysis must be able to account for not only stable structural relations, but also the emergence, reproduction and transformation of structures. This issue is discussed by relating to debates on structure and agency in sociology and notions of emergence, conflict and inertia in various strands of economic theory, among which Hayekian, Marxian, institutional economics and recent advances in Schumpeterian and evolutionary economics have been especially noticeable. The essay concludes by reflecting on challenges to the empirical study of emergence, reproduction and transformation of economic and social structures.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.