ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The Road to Serfdom in the Light of The Great Transformation: The “Stark Utopia” after 70 years
Author: Özel Hüseyin
The paper is an attempt at comparing two opposite accounts, developed to explain the same phenomenon, “collectivism” in the form of fascism or socialism in two books: Karl Polanyi’s The Great Transformation, and Friedrich A. Hayek’s The Road of Serfdom. However, in this comparison the idea of unintended consequences, which postulates as an answer to the problem of “order” that even though the actions of individual human beings are carried out on their intentions, such actions will have some consequences that were not intended by any of these individuals, is taken as a reference point because both Polanyi and Hayek use this idea as an important ingredient of their social theories. However, it is argued in the paper firstly that the idea of unintended consequences cannot fulfill its promise, namely to explain the social order, especially in Hayek’s case. In Hayek, it remains essentially a mere abstraction and reduces to a functional argument based on the “representative individual” whereas in Polanyi it was handled on a more concrete level, conceived in terms of interactions between individuals, classes and other sections of the society. In particular, Polanyi’s notion of the “double movement” is capable of why and how the “invisible hand,” as presented in the liberal accounts, would lead to a “stark utopia.” It is also argued that it is not the differences in the use of the idea of unintended consequences per se but the difference between the respective visions of these two thinkers, concerning human beings and freedom, which constitutes the essential, unbridgeable gap between their social theories.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


