ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Reconciling a divide: looking for the roots of disagreement within the critical side in the Cambridge-Cambridge controversy
Author: Lazzarini Andres
The present paper deals with some late historical developments of the Cambridge-Cambridge controversy, with a particular focus on the critical side (Cambridge, UK) of this theoretical conflict. In the paper I first summarise and contextualize the most relevant contributions of the critics in what I have called the first phase of the capital theory debate. In that phase, I argue, the critics' arguments proved firmly robust in the task of criticizing the neoclassical price and distribution theory. The outcomes of the first phase of the controversy were broadly acknowledged, even by some well-known scholars of the MIT side of the debates. However, the paper also examines a rather overlooked feature in the controversies, which has been the divide that emerged within the critical side in a second phase of the debates. In this connection, I discuss the methodological schism that emerged between Joan Robinson and Pierangelo Garegnani and identify the analytical roots of their disagreement. On the one hand, Robinson and other Cambridge economists tried to swiftly provide an alternative theory which linked distribution and output growth, leaving aside the analysis of the determinants of value and distribution. On the other hand, Garegnani and other scholars strongly influenced by the work of Sraffa, were mainly concerned in value and distribution theory, which they regarded as key in their rejection of marginalist theory, leaving analysis of output and accumulation for a successive step in their research program. The aim of the paper not only is to clarify the reasons for their disagreement but also to find some hints about how a reconciliation of the critics' divergent positions might have been achieved. With this latter aim in mind, I analyse both Robinson's analysis of processes in 'historical time' and Garegnani's distinction between economic analysis within the 'core' of classical economic theory (e.g.., relationships between prices and distribution) and analysis 'outside the core'(e.g., relationships between distribution and output). Examination and reconstruction of the two branches of the critically oriented side of the controversies may lead to a way forward that may settle their disagreement and therefore provide a robust heterodox economic approach that is so much needed today.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


