ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Can China Change Its Industrialization Path: Reconsidering the 2004-5 Industrial Policy Debate in China
Author: Liu Qunyi


The more recent chemical accident in Fujian and frequent winter-smog in most of east China cities arouse a policy debate again and again, with the similar topic to the one held almost 10 years ago, that is, does China need to change its industrialization path? Although the government has answered the question with the obscure attitude of “grow first, clean up later” since 1978 and made great efforts to rein in pollution, the clash of the opinions does not stop, yet leads further to the reconsideration of the development strategy, especially the efficiency of industrial policies from 2006 then on, as there was an attempt to revise the policy target in the year. The afterwards policy of the 11th Five-Year Plan (2006-10) originated indeed from the debate two years ago. In 2004, one of the most famous economists Wu Jinglian submitted a symbolic proposal to the Chinese People’s Political Consultative (CPPCC), referring to the necessity of policy adjustment from heavy industries to light ones and service sectors, which was opposed by another predominant economist Li Yining later. The debate lasted for more than two years and involved quite a few economists and policymakers into the controversy. Contrast to the former-Soviet policy standard in the 1950s, the opponents turned to the economic theories such as W.G. Hoffmann’s Index and received comprehensive support from local governments. The 11th Five-Year Plan ended the debate with the emphasis on “a new resource-economizing path of industrialization” and set a limit to heavy industries (HI). However, the decision of central government did not obtain a positive reaction from local authorities and non-governmental sectors. China has witnessed a massive wave of investments in HI until today. By reconsidering the 2004-5 Debate the paper will focus on the policy content in the controversy of economic theories and beyond, namely, the relationship between the theories and formation of policies, in which stages of diversification and the M-form of Chinese governance are highlights. The paper is divided into 6 parts. After the introduction the background of the debate is demonstrated with a retrospect of the HI development in China; the third part reviews the whole process of the Debate and compares the following policy with its responses through the data of industrial sectors; in the fourth part we analyze the dilemma between market and governments to argue that the former strong government is faced with the real challenge from the market and have to abide by the rule of market other than to override it; then an extensive study with other East Asian economies is made to explore the theoretical meaning of the policy debate. Part 6 goes with a few concluding remarks.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.