ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Beyond the development/underdevelopment nexus: Marx’s understanding of the development of capitalism
Author: Pradella Lucia


The contradictory effects of neoliberalism and of the growth of the BRICS and other big emerging market economies have revived debates on under/development, dependency, and uneven exchange. Critically engaging with a supposed ‘orthodox Marxism’, scholars such as Baran (1957) and Frank (1966) and dependency theorists argued that the underdevelopment of the periphery was the very consequence of the international expansion of capitalist social relations. They argued that Marx’s main work, on the contrary, would be mainly focused on the core of the capitalist system and inapplicable to the analysis of the periphery, up to the point of believing in the homogenising consequences of universal interdependence (Frank, 1978; Baran, 1973; Dos Santos, 2000; Amin, 1974; Wallerstein, 1985). My paper revisits these debates in the light of my research into Marx’s analysis of the development of capitalism in his main work, Capital, and in his articles and notebooks on colonialism under publication in the Marx-Engels Gesamtausgabe (MEGA²) (Pradella, 2010 and 2014). After presenting my main research questions based on the literature review in the first section, the paper briefly discusses the content of Marx’s Notebooks of London (1850—3) in the following section. It argues that Marx’s critique of the quantity theory of money was a turning point in his analysis of the development of capitalism. This critique, in fact, allowed Marx to theorise not only the historical but also the logical primacy of the world market, overcoming the assumption of the nation state as the unit of analysis of development. Section 3 then argues that, differently from what is generally assumed, in Capital Marx did not analyse Britain as a national economy, but as a world polarizing and ever-expanding system. The paper then turns more specifically to the relationship between the level of abstraction of Capital Volume 1 and the analysis of the uneven international development of capitalism. Section 4 presents Marx’s attempts in the 1861-63 Manuscript to clarify the relation between countries with different levels of productivity, examining the world-market modifications of the law of value and the corresponding advantages or disadvantages for the nations involved in international trade. The paper concludes that only by radically reconceptualising development itself can we understand the uneven development of capitalism beyond the development/underdevelopment nexus.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.