ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The residual determination of the rent of land in Adam Smith’s theory of value and distribution
Author: Laino Freitas Alexandre


The objective of this paper is to show that Adam Smith’s theory of value and distribution is coherent with the idea that the wage, profit and rent of land rates distribute a given physical produce. Therefore, each social class cannot receive a greater quantity of commodities unless the other classes’ losses are of the exact same amount. This affirmative directly contradicts Marx’s “adding-up interpretation”, whereby Smith would have independently determined the rates of wages, profits and rents of land before adding them up to determine the natural prices of the commodities. The adding up interpretation fails to acknowledge the residual explanation of the rent of land rate, determined by technology and the rates of wages and profits. Smith also considered that the basic laborer would consume mostly agricultural products. Since agricultural produces’ natural prices had a direct rent of land component that was residually determined, they were not affected by wages or profit increases. Therefore, manufactures prices relative to agricultural prices were positively connected with the rates of wages and profits. As a consequence, profit increases would have little impact on the real wage and wage increases would not have a direct impact on profits. These idiosyncrasies in Smith’s work related to his theory of rent of land led many interprets to overlook the connection among the distributive variables and to accept the “adding up interpretation”. I will show that the residual determination of the rent of land rate set forth in the eleventh chapter of WN resulted also in a residual determination of the share of rent in total produce. In fact, Smith’s theory of value is re-interpreted as the theoretical linkage among physical production and monetary revenues, allowing Smith to subordinate the later to the former. The reduction of all costs of production to the value added by wages, profits and rents created equivalence among the production of commodities and the total amount of revenues received. The "original revenues" were only the ones derived from the production of new commodities. Therefore, the theory of value does not deny the binding constraint on distribution but, otherwise, introduces it by linking monetary revenue to physical production. The article is composed of six sections: 1) Introduction; 2) The "adding up interpretation"; 3) the determination of the rent of land rate and share; 4) relative prices, profits and wages; 5) reinterpreting the role of Smith's theory of value and distribution; 6) conclusion.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.