ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Ricardo and Sraffa on lands
Author: BIDARD Christian
The Ricardian dynamics study the law governing the succession of methods when demand increases and meets a scarcity constraint on lands. The outgoing marginal method is the one which meets the physical constraint. Then the market price of corn starts rising, with indirect effects on rents and on the prices of commodities whose production requires corn. The direction of the change in the price-and-rent vector being identified, its intensity obeys the following rule: the incoming marginal method is the first non-operated method which reaches the ruling level of profitability when the price of corn increases. That law of succession gives the new long-term price-and-rent vector and the new marginal method. We first apply the rule to the choice, evoked by Ricardo, between extension and intensification of cultivation in a simple corn model, then show that the scope of the law is general. A number of conclusions follow from the law. For the theory of intensive rent, the most significant consequence echoes a well known paradox of capital theory: since the incoming method is determined by a profitability condition, it is not ensured that it is more productive than the marginal method it replaces and can therefore meet a higher level of demand. Sraffa’s text is ambiguous on that point: either Sraffa did not see the possible contradiction between the physical side and the value side of the new potential equilibrium or, if he did, he wrongly thought that the positivity of rent suffices to guarantee that profitability and productivity go hand in hand in the agricultural framework. His over-optimistic conclusions have been challenged by post-Sraffian works, which have pointed out some difficulties in rent theory. Unfortunately, the static framework adopted by most post-Sraffian studies does not allow them to explain the origin of these difficulties. We reexamine the questions of uniqueness and multiplicity in the light of the law of succession. Eventually, it is shown that the Ricardian dynamic approach has been independently rediscovered by mathematicians 150 years later: it coincides with the parametric Lemke algorithm used to solve linear complementarity problems.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)