ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: ‘A harsh and inhumane science’ Dutch 19th century economists on inequality
Author: Schoorl Evert


Introduction In the kingdom of the Netherlands (1815-1830 the united kingdom of the Netherlands and Belgium) the poor question was high on the agenda until the middle of the 19th century. One of King William the first’s measures to get the stagnating Dutch economy moving was the encouragement of economics to be taught as an academic subject. In the eighteen-twenties a broad institutionalization of economics came about. Most professors taught one or another version of Smithian-Saysian, classical economics. Only after 1850 Ricardianism got a foothold, not in the universities but at The Netherlands Bank, with W.C. Mees as its director. However from the beginning a strand of anti-classical economics was present, at first in professor Tydeman’s teaching at Leyden university. H.P.G. Quack in Utrecht, and later at The Netherlands Bank and the Amsterdam university, could even be labeled as a forerunner of the German Historical School. But also a staunch liberal economist such as Jeronimo de Bosch Kemper in Amsterdam, while accepting poverty as an unfortunate side effect of capitalism, deeply cared about charity from his Christian background. From 1870 on the economics landscape was dominated by the formidable character of N.G. Pierson – professor, central bank president, and prime minister. His economic literature reviews in De Gids, an influential literary and political journal, were effective in informing the general public, but also in preventing the supporters of the German Historical School from becoming influential. However this movement was by no means neglected in the Netherlands, but its adherents were kept away from academic chairs. A considerable number of them were active in politics, where they were active in legislation preventing child labour, and in social policy at large. In the first section of the paper, the role of the king and of his minister, advisor, and MP Gijsbert Karel van Hogendorp in promoting economics is sketched. In the second, Ackersdijck in Utrecht and Tydeman in Leyden are described as the role models of classical and anti-classical economists. Section three discusses the alternative, agrarian perspective for the Dutch economy proposed by baron Sloet. Mees and Ricardianism are the subject of section four. Quack and evangelical socialism of section five. With Pierson in section six, the international dimension comes to the fore. The last section is devoted to the influence of the Historical School. Conclusion: the subject of economic inequality may not always have been high on the political agenda in the nineteenth century, but among the Dutch economists it was always an important subject.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.