ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Walras and Wicksell on monetary reform: how many nuances?
Author: ALCOUFFE Alain, Boianovsky Mauro
Between November 1893 and November 1900, Walras and Wicksell exchanged nine letters written in French. These letters as well as the reviews of Walras’ books by Wicksell provide us interesting insights not only on their strategies in order to improve their prestige or their reputation but also on their ideas on monetary issues. Walras is clearly primarily concerned with his proselytism in favor of mathematical economics, and his efforts to promote a new generation of mathematical economists. Wicksell tries to build on the heritage of famous forerunners while taking an inventory of their legacies and developing his own ideas. Simultaneously, Wicksell insists that he does not behave as a subservient follower of the master and on several points he contradicts Walras. To begin with, he claims that Walras “completely overlooked the significance of time in production”. That is the reason why he adopts Böhm-Bawerk’s theory of capital and rejects Walras’ one. That leads to a discussion of methodological issues as Wicksell argues that Walras uses “fiction” in order to define the part played by capital in production. In his reply, Walras defends his method, which he presents as an “abstraction” and not as a “fiction”. But their divergences were not limited to methodological issues, and Wicksell criticized Walras’ plans for monetary reforms. Their divergences were initially understated by Wicksell, who ensures that his theory differs from Walras’ one only by “a nuance”, but the two authors did not hold the same conception of money as the discussion of bimetallism shows. Whereas Walras in the context of the Latin monetary union gave up reluctantly the metallic conception of money, Wicksell focused on credit and fiduciary money. Walras wrote his article « Monnaie d’or avec billon d’argent régulateur » in view of the conference for the monetary union (later called Latin monetary union) to be held in Paris. It included a mathematical proof of the viability of bimetallism. Walras consistently campaigned for his proposal, insisting that he had gathered empirical evidence to support it. Wicksell gave some credit to Walras’ proposal, which could avoid “most of the monetary problems that have marked the last three decades”. However, Walras’ proposal was in Wicksell’ eyes a very imperfect tool to regulate with appropriate promptness the rate of interest in order to avoid a discrepancy with the natural rate of interest. Eventually the differing positions appear to be related to the role of time in economic life and analysis, as far as the theories of capital and money are concerned.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)