ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Colson, the French liberal School and the question of social insurances at the begining ot the XXth century
Author: De Paoli Joachim
The question of social insurances – included the insurance for old age – is a recurrent problem in economy, either in theory or in practice. The law make them gradually compulsory from the 1898 law on worker’s compensation to 1930 with the law especially concerning insurance disease. The aim of this communication is to report the debates among French liberal economists during the creation of the laws making social insurances compulsory. The analysis will focus on the contributions of a nowadays not very studied author but however who had an important role in his time: the economist engineer Clément Colson. Indeed, he had an important role as economist and as official and politician too. His vision of social insurances will be compared to the vision of others liberal economists of his time representing the different currents of the French liberal school : the ultraliberal Guyot, the liberal moderate Leroy-Beaulieu, the “leplaysien” economist Cheysson and Jacques Rueff, one of the famous students of Colson. The analysis will concentrate on several points. On the first hand, studying the different points of view about social insurances of the time, we will demonstrate that the different members of the French liberal school have divergent opinions. So, Guyot opposes to any intervention of the State and defends the system of civil liability; Leroy-Beaulieu is for encouraging insurance, seen like a collective saving, but at the same time he is against State intervention; Cheysson defends a State intervention to allow workers to be insured and suggests a “Liberalism of State” in which he concilates compulsory insurance and insurance’s choice freedom for the boss. It will also be shown that the analysis of the different types of social insurances is not the same according to the risk they face. So, while the most accepted social insurances are those concerning accidents and sickness, all the authors don’t think that retirement should be ensured; unemployment insurance is rejected because the risk is not independent of the insured. Then, exposing the Colson argumentation, the target will be better knowing this author’s thought, presented by Bousquet and Divisia as the most important French economist of the first quarter of the century after Walras. We will see that theory and practice are very linked for him. So, workers not having necessary resources for providing, the State has to take into account the Social question and to intervene to enable them to be protected against the risks they face. Presenting his vision of social insurances, we will see it is possible to classify him among the liberal economists granting paradoxically an important place to the State. Finally, the decisive role that Colson could have on the thought of Rueff will be highlighted showing that the unemployment theory developed by Rueff is very inspired by the development of his master on the unemployment insurance.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)