ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Bernard Mandeville on the Role of Education
Author: Prendergast Renee


Not much notice was taken of first (1714) edition of Bernard Mandeville’s Fable of the Bees. Its infamy began with the publication of the second edition containing Mandeville’s attack on the Charity schools in 1723. As Mandeville noted , proponents of the schools argued that they would provide the poor with opportunity and promote manners and morality thereby benefiting the whole society. Mandeville’s attack was many pronged. As far as opportunity was concerned, he argued that being deprived of it was no worse than not having money when the poor had the same inclinations to spend as others. He disputed the view that lack of education was the cause of the main social evils, pointed out that education had an opportunity cost in terms of lost earnings and criticised the nature and quality of the training provided by the schools themselves. Mandeville argued that parents could be relied upon to look out for the apprenticeship that was advantageous and within their means and that this mechanism would be adequate to ensure the socially desirable mix of trades and skills. Mandeville did not deny that there were circumstances where the promotion of education was necessary for the development of the economy but, in his view, this was not the case in England. Mandeville’s attack on the charity schools should not be interpreted to mean that he regarded education as unimportant. As a matter of fact, he saw education in its broadest sense as having a vital role in the accumulation of knowledge which was necessary for economic and social progress. In his response to an attack by Bishop Berkeley, he wrote ’Your design is to make men copy after the beautiful original….Mine is to enforce the necessity of education’ (Mandeville, 1732) Given the extent of controversy surrounding Mandeville’s attack on the charity schools, it is interesting to examine the extent to which it features in other writings of the period. Cantillon (1755) provided a clear analysis of the way in which the numbers of labourers, craftsmen etc. proportion themselves to the demand for them and concurred that the charity schools in England and similar proposals in France were useless. Although not uncritical of the charity schools, Adam Smith took a positive view of the role of general education and advocated its public provision. In Smith’s view, even those in the lowest occupations could benefit from some grounding in reading, writing and arithmetic.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.