ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: “Inequality” as logical and historical notion.
Author: Chaplygina Irina
L. Robbins in his famous Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science noted that validity of a theory “cannot rest upon a mere appeal to “History””. “The frequent concomitance of certain phenomena in time… cannot by itself be taken to imply a definite causal relationship”. At the same time the causal relationship is an invention of our mind, it is a mode of our reasoning (Hume). In general the laws of logic that we utilize by describing the reality and on which we base our vision of reality are not empirical. Inequality is one of the logical notions. It means violation of equality. The notion of equality implies the possibility to compare different objects and the possibility to define one criterion for such comparison. This procedure demands qualitative homogeneity of the objects. Economic phenomena are heterogeneous and multivariable. Therefore it is difficult to rigorously define notion “equality” and “inequality”. Any set of phenomena, even belonging to the same class, can be ordered according to lots of criteria. So we can construct many hierarchical systems and each of them can be the basis for one conception of inequality. For example, A.Sen in Idea of Justice admits that there are many criteria for determining inequality, and the consensus does not exist here. But for constructing one logically strong theory of inequality we must choose only one criterion. Here we ought to take the arbitrary value judgment, i.e. we should choose one of the numerous criteria and assign to it the crucial importance. Therefore, when we bring up the problem of inequality we always import our value judgments to the real world: our moral values (ideas of egalitarianism), or epistemological values (logical norms, rules of mathematical equation), or social values. In the economic science the notion of equality makes sense in case it correlates to some economic purposes or values: as means of providing reproduction, maximizing public wealth (utilitarianism), stimulating the growth of effective demand, liberating the productive forces of the individual, promoting the efficient use of sources, etc. Thus, the notion of inequality appears to be a logical and normative category. In this context, it seems that Russian economic schools of the turn of XIX-XX centuries demonstrate an alternative approach. In particular the "social distribution theory" was based on the historical laws of distribution and the theory of Russian Marxism - on the principles of historical necessity.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)