ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: An Inequality of perceptiveness in economic thought: Austrian School and the debate on cooperative movement
Author: TRINCADO AZNAR Estrella


Mises made some observations on the Cooperative businesses, that is to say, firms collectively owned and run by their workers. According to him, they may perfectly emerge in a free society, however, the elimination of the private businessman is a sacrilege. This intermediary is a especially perceptive agent that needs to think on its own and needs encouragement to have clear ideas: he is describe as the talented individual. He seems to have different philosophical and psychological features than the common people. Its existence does not increase, but reduces, sales costs. It is true that the official academic representatives at Vienna University of the economic theory of cooperatives (Genossenschaftswesen) often belonged to the collectivist camp (Spann circle). But, Friedrich Wieser wrote a piece on the cooperatives (Genossenschaften) favoring social economics and a mixed economy in the tradition of the eighteenth century cameralism, in contrast with Menger’s individualism. John O Neill points to epistemological parallels between Hayek and Otto Neurath, who advocated a kind of “associationist socialism” in which meso-level social institutions (like cooperatives) would play a major role. This article will deal with the debate on cooperativism, trying to ascertain if the Austrian School of Economics defended an unequal psychology of the agents. In the Austrian School world, the market process is driven by alertness, or entrepreneurial discovery (Kirzner), where the subjective perception of information is an essential element. Shmanske calculates the costs of discovery and concludes that the capacity for alertness will be greater in a market-oriented, low-tax economy. But Carson reconciles the Austrian and Marxist anti-statist theories. He demonstrates that the end of liberal democracy and its replacement with a decentralized political order would naturally generate an economic order where the worker-oriented enterprise replaces the capitalist corporation as the dominant mode of economic organization. Murray Rothbard expressed sympathy for many of the criticisms of state capitalism advanced by the classical socialists, including Marx and Bakunin. However, the Austrian economists do not derive optimism concerning mankind's future evolution from their epistemological convictions. Intellectuals must disseminate a correct grasp of how a market economy operates to teach those blinded by ignorance and emotions. Mises thought that feminism was a revolt against nature akin to socialism and assumed the existence of “better races” and thought that Eurocentrism was the proper outlook. He based his arguments on a somewhat elitist theory. For him, the masses do not think. Thinkers in a market economy are, of course, entrepreneurs. Rothbard also believed in the superiority of the elite, and that society is filled with "ineducable masses”. He does not attribute the problems of blacks or other minorities to racism and prejudice, but to parasitic values of idleness and irresponsibility found in those communities.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.