ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Searching for a lineage of Adam Smith's last teachings: Thomas Chalmers
Author: Garbo Lorenzo
This paper builds on my previous work on the teachings on superior prudence (wisdom) found in the sixth edition of Adam Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments (TMS), where I offered an interpretation of the “great school of self command” as Smith’s vision of a dialectical process between external and internal approbation that is capable of transforming individual dependence on social praise into a dialogue between materialistic and moral concerns, which would lead to a progressively wiser existence. The exploration of a possible lineage of these teachings in the first decades of the nineteenth century offers Thomas Chalmers as an important candidate. A review of his collection of writings, discourses, and depositions; interpretations of his work by Searle (1998), Hilton (1985, 1986), Waterman (1991, 2002, 2006), and Wilson and Dixon (2004, 2010, 2013); and his biographies by Hanna (1849) and Blaikie (1896), reveal a doctrine of conscience and formation of character altogether similar to the path toward wisdom proposed by Smith in the last revisions to TMS. While Smith entrusts the individual with the ability to distinguish the voices of external and internal spectators and thus the pulls of passion and moral integrity, Chalmers envisions a clerisy of Christian educators dedicated to enabling the individual to avoid confusions between narrow self-interest and moral alignment, and enter a path towards wisdom that he calls “the school for nobleness of character” (The Application of Christianity to the Commercial and Ordinary Affairs of Life, 1820, p. 135). Similarities between Smith’s “great school of self-command” and Chalmers’ “school for the nobleness of character” abound: for instance, both paths are fed by the opportunities offered by the world of affairs, and it is the conscious engagement with both external and internal stimuli that propels the individual towards a wiser existence; both “schools” are accessible by everyone, independently of intellect or “nobleness of condition”; and both paths never end, as Chalmers like Smith envisions the individual on the path toward wisdom as only able to approximate perfect standards of moral alignment and integrity. Within a historiographical framework, the paper argues that the role assigned by Smith to the demigod within the breast was taken on by Chalmers’ (and Wilberforce’s before him) Christian clerisy. The main objective of such clerisy was not conversion to Christianity, even though that would remain its greatest achievement: it was to “make it possible for a man to give his hand to the duties of his secular occupation, and, at the same time, to maintain the sacredness of heart,” to pose itself as a dialectic force against the idolization of economic success and the delusional strength of social mirroring and, for the poorest portion of the population, against a self that for a variety of circumstances may be prevented from developing character. (The Application of Christianity to the Commercial and Ordinary Affairs of Life, 1820, pp. iii-v)
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)