ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Beyond paradigms: a methodological approach of inequalities through Deaton, Piketty and De Soto
Author: Kontzler Hélène, Michel Leroy
In a « kuhnian » paradigm, every school of thought has his founding father. Such a Manichean vision of economics is probably no longer acceptable now that economics has become a full social science. This paperseeks to demonstrate that a methodological and non-paradigmatic approach could anchor economics in History, yet in a way different from the traditional “kuhnian” one. We pursue this endeavor through an analysis of the works of three authors, Deaton, De Soto and Piketty. We show that from a methodological point of view, inequalities, for example, can be analyzed beyond any ideological paradigm. Following a paradigmatic approach, Deaton would be classified as a liberal, De Soto a neo-liberal and Piketty a Marxist. If wethink beyond these schools of thought,another perspective could be given with new keys of understanding such contemporary matters as inequalities - and with new solutions. We will demonstrate that authors using an inductive methodology give the State a central role in economic phenomena, insofar as they have a macroeconomic approach. For instance Piketty focuses on a tax solution to solve inequalities, a State solution par excellence. Such an approach is also part of Marx’ work, as well as of the German historic school, ofSmith and ofthe English school. A deductive methodologyof treating the analysis of inequalitiesis proposed by De Soto. This methodology leads to« laissez faire » solutions.Quesnay, Turgot, Proudhon and the whole French school share these kinds of individualistic solutions. Finally, an individualisticpoint of view in limited but efficientorganizations is used by Deaton. This approach could also be considered as part of an adductive methodology.In the same type of framework could be also includedHayek and the Austrian school.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)